Peanut Exec Invokes the Fifth
DH | Feb 11, 2009 | Comments 7
Listening to radio news while driving my car today, I heard the President of Peanut Corporation of America, Stewart Parnell, invoke the Fifth Amendment, and refuse to answer questions from members of Congress about the massive peanut salmonella poisoning at his company … and, I nearly drove off the road!
Salmonella contamination of peanuts has been traced to a Peanut Corporation plant in Blakely, Georgia. The outbreak continues to spread, and has sicken at least 600 people, more than half of them children, and may have killed eight people.
With such overwhelming evidence against a major food company, why did Parnell choose to evoke the Fifth Amendment, and who advised him to do so? I do not have the answers, yet.
I can tell you that his actions today before Congress were not wise. What he said, in fact, was self-incriminating and downright foolish. He demonstrated no compassion, no sympathy for those who were sickened or may have died, and no concern.
Feds have his emails to employees, instructing them to ship contaminated peanuts. There are words for Parnell’s behavior … outrageous and arrogant.
We live in an era when leadership mandates more accountability, more openness and transparency, and more cooperation. Parnell’s behavior, on the other hand, likely will land him in court. What he said was irresponsible.
The president of the U.S. peanut company blamed for a salmonella outbreak refused to answer questions before Congress on Wednesday, while internal company messages showed him complaining about lost profits while the scare was investigated.
The contamination has forced one of the biggest food recalls in U.S. history, scared Americans away from one of their favorite foods and brought the U.S. Food and Drug Administration under intense scrutiny.
What Parnell did before Congress today will make this an even bigger story, and one that unquestionably will focus on his lack of action in favor of profits and greed.
Filed Under: Featured • Media Relations






Hey David;
I too was amazed when I heard Parnell do this. I can’t get over the total disregard for what the company has done.
Thanks for your thoughts!
Rus
Dr. Rus,
Honored to have a comment from you. On the peanut issue, words fail to fully describe the irresponsible words of the company’s CEO.
David
Thanks for bringing this up. It is so sad, there are no limits to human stupidity… Where has this guy been the last 100 years?
Hi, David. In addition to “arrogant,” “outrageous” and “irresponsible,” you might add just plain “stupid.” Not even taking the simple step of acknowledging the seriousness of the issue or the plight of the victims is just classic “lawyering up” as they say on Law & Order. Just goes to magnify the story and dig the company hole even deeper.
If pleading the 5th wasn’t incriminating enough, his instruction to employees to ship contaminated peanuts was outrageous. His lack of respect for human life is despicable.
Is there anything worse than knowingly selling contaminated products to children? Parnell couldn’t have handled it much worse.
Whoever said silence speaks louder than words never uttered a truer sentence. I hope he’s screaming his head off when he’s led away in chains…